New York vs Vancouver: 33% vs 14%
New York wins on savings rate by 19 percentage-points. Rent burden: 25% in New York vs 35% in Vancouver. Median incomes: $170,000 (USD) vs C$90,000 (CAD).
New York
- Savings rate
- 33%
- Median income
- $170,000 /yr
- Median rent
- $3,500 /mo
- Rent burden
- 25%
- Total core costs
- $6,000 /mo
- Years to FIRE
- 32 yrs
Vancouver
- Savings rate
- 14%
- Median income
- C$90,000 /yr
- Median rent
- C$2,600 /mo
- Rent burden
- 35%
- Total core costs
- C$4,500 /mo
- Years to FIRE
- 107 yrs
Verdict
- Savings rate: New York (33%) beats Vancouver (14%) by 19 pp.
- Rent burden: New York (25%) is more affordable than Vancouver (35%).
- FIRE timeline: New York reaches financial independence in ~32 years, vs ~107 years in Vancouver.
- 5-year wealth gap: The 19-pp annual savings-rate gap compounds to ~95 percentage-points of gross income over five years — directly attributable to local cost structure.
New York vs Vancouver — FAQ
Which city has the higher savings rate, New York or Vancouver?+
New York has the higher savings rate at 33% of gross income, compared to 14% in Vancouver. That is a 19 percentage-point gap. Over a 5-year horizon, the gap compounds to roughly 95 percentage-points of gross income — meaningful for anyone optimising long-term wealth.
What is the income gap between New York and Vancouver?+
Median New York household income (mid-band) is around $170,000/year (USD). In Vancouver it is around C$90,000/year (CAD). Different currencies make a direct gap meaningless without an exchange rate, so compare savings rate (%) and rent burden (%) instead.
Is rent worse in New York or Vancouver?+
Rent burden is higher in Vancouver: rent eats 35% of gross median income there, vs 25% in New York. Median monthly rent is $3,500 in New York and C$2,600 in Vancouver. New York is the better city for renters at the median income level.
Which city is better for early retirement (FIRE), New York or Vancouver?+
Using a simple 25x-expenses FIRE benchmark, a mid-income earner in New York could reach financial independence in roughly 32 years at the current local savings rate, vs 107 years in Vancouver. New York is the better FIRE city for mid-income earners based on local savings rate and cost structure.
What about cost-of-living adjusted — does New York still win?+
Yes. Savings rate already factors in the local cost of living, because it is calculated as (income − expenses) ÷ income using BLS Consumer Expenditure Survey 2023. New York's 33% rate is the cost-adjusted figure — it already reflects what residents actually save after paying rent and other expenses. The 19 percentage-point lead over Vancouver is real, not a currency illusion.
Methodology
Savings rates from BLS Consumer Expenditure Survey 2023 for New York (United States) and Statistics Canada SHS 2023 for Vancouver (Canada). Median income is the midpoint of the default income band for each city. Rent burden is annualised rent divided by gross median income. Years to FIRE assumes a 25× annual expenses target, saved at the local benchmark rate, with no investment growth — a deliberately conservative proxy for ordering cities, not a forecast.
Comparisons across different currencies should focus on percentages (savings rate, rent burden), not absolute amounts.